As The Puritan Fathers Used To Say:  “Every Time A Spliff I Light, I Thank The Lord Who Made Me White.”  
(click)
The blatant racism of policies like this is enough to make your head explode.  The idea that anyone could ignore decades of medical, social-scientific, and psychological research and still believe in the concept of “gateway drug” is genuinely incredible to me.  No wonder the NYPD doesn’t have enough manpower to investigate violent crime like rape and the disappearance of sex workers - they’re too busy keeping people from accidentally enjoying themselves. 
More importantly from a philosophical perspective, this article neatly illustrates the difference between “identity politics,” which are concerned primarily with recognition and self-identity, and, on the other hand, genuine social oppression, which is first and foremost a function of action and privation.  In other words, I consider a social group oppressed if for any reason, systemic, ideological, legal, or other, they are denied access to or else suffer different consequences as a result of a particular action.  I use “privation” here in the Spinozan sense to mean the conceptual absence of something elsewhere recognized as a positive entity (in this case, the right to walk down the street smoking a joint without being arrested). 
A while back I wrote this post discussing Nietzsche’s critique of Hegel’s Master-Slave Dialectic, which basically boils down to the fact that only a slave would consider freedom to equal recognition from a master; “identity politics” is thus basically a form of slave mentality, concerned as it is with representation.  This is exactly the reason that I consider gay marriage a genuine political issue, while at the same time considering groups like GLAAD and the Human Rights Campaign to be self-serving, reactionary douche-fests:  because oppression consists in the privation or limitation of action, not in the representational politics of Glee. 

As The Puritan Fathers Used To Say:  “Every Time A Spliff I Light, I Thank The Lord Who Made Me White.” 

(click)

The blatant racism of policies like this is enough to make your head explode.  The idea that anyone could ignore decades of medical, social-scientific, and psychological research and still believe in the concept of “gateway drug” is genuinely incredible to me.  No wonder the NYPD doesn’t have enough manpower to investigate violent crime like rape and the disappearance of sex workers - they’re too busy keeping people from accidentally enjoying themselves. 

More importantly from a philosophical perspective, this article neatly illustrates the difference between “identity politics,” which are concerned primarily with recognition and self-identity, and, on the other hand, genuine social oppression, which is first and foremost a function of action and privation.  In other words, I consider a social group oppressed if for any reason, systemic, ideological, legal, or other, they are denied access to or else suffer different consequences as a result of a particular action.  I use “privation” here in the Spinozan sense to mean the conceptual absence of something elsewhere recognized as a positive entity (in this case, the right to walk down the street smoking a joint without being arrested). 

A while back I wrote this post discussing Nietzsche’s critique of Hegel’s Master-Slave Dialectic, which basically boils down to the fact that only a slave would consider freedom to equal recognition from a master; “identity politics” is thus basically a form of slave mentality, concerned as it is with representation.  This is exactly the reason that I consider gay marriage a genuine political issue, while at the same time considering groups like GLAAD and the Human Rights Campaign to be self-serving, reactionary douche-fests:  because oppression consists in the privation or limitation of action, not in the representational politics of Glee

  1. mrojasss reblogged this from fucktheory
  2. iliket2look reblogged this from fucktheory
  3. tjjourian reblogged this from polypeopleofcolor
  4. polypeopleofcolor reblogged this from blackraincloud
  5. oprimer reblogged this from harperisafairy
  6. thefactswehate reblogged this from fucktheory
  7. telegantmess reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine and added:
    I’m not sure I completely agree with the complete dismissal of representation as a tool for justice, but this is...
  8. endwealth reblogged this from kadalkavithaigal and added:
    I agree with everything you said, however I think representation is an important thing. Fair representation can bring...
  9. emanners reblogged this from kadalkavithaigal
  10. byallflowers reblogged this from kadalkavithaigal
  11. steppingoncracks reblogged this from kadalkavithaigal
  12. thefistofartemis reblogged this from kadalkavithaigal
  13. uatjonc reblogged this from blackraincloud and added:
    I would think they meant unequal treatment in such instances as sentencing and punishment for crimes. Like how there is...
  14. thenaturalessence reblogged this from manif3stlove
  15. manif3stlove reblogged this from so-treu
  16. blackraincloud reblogged this from t-akver and added:
    Ohhhh ok. Yeah, there was a lot going on in some of these sentences and that one in particular I just couldn’t make...
  17. t-akver reblogged this from blackraincloud and added:
    That sentence uses parallel structure in a weird way. I’m pretty sure what it’s saying is: "I consider a social group...
  18. blackmamba503 reblogged this from so-treu
  19. dadgenes reblogged this from so-treu
  20. strugglingtobeheard reblogged this from so-treu and added:
    The justifications these fuckwad policitions use for shit like this is amazing. Its quite upsetting. Very good...
  21. so-treu reblogged this from guerrillamamamedicine and added:
    ^that last bolded section
  22. incurablehippie reblogged this from punanipickle
  23. punanipickle reblogged this from eckleburgs-eyes
  24. gendervariant reblogged this from bohemianarthouse
  25. tygermama reblogged this from tinyfist
  26. fucktheory posted this